 |
| |
 |
|
ANTI-AGING
DRUGS AND SUPPLEMENTS |
|
 |
| |
5.2
DRUGS WITH CONTROVERSIAL
OR UNPROVEN ANTI-AGING EFFECT (side-effects) |
|
|
|
|
|
12 elderly men (aged 61-81) were injected daily with
high levels of Human Growth Hormone (HGH). The results
showed that there was a 9% increase in lean body mass
and 14% decrease in fatty tissues. The men reported
also an enhanced sense of well-being. HRT (hormone
replacement therapy) has grown in popularity very
much and not only HGH but other hormones (e.g. DHEA)
have also become involved. There is, of course, no
doubt that they help in some way or the other - they
do increase muscle mass, bone mineral content and
there is fat redistribution. And while many of the
treated people report feeling better, double-blind
studies on men aged 70 to 85 have shown no difference
between test and placebo-controlled subjects. Although
studies on rodents have proven the life-extending
functions of GH, the results of them vary greatly.
In one mice study, a prolonged life span of GH-receiving
mice was observed, but the study was not conducted
properly - the strain of mice was not long-lived anyway
and the study was not run until the very end, so proper
results can be observed. Contrasting, another rat
study has shown absolutely no difference in disease
patterns or maximum survival period between test rats
and control rats. In conclusion, one might comment
that HGH is very controversial and there is a great
room for doubts about its effectiveness.
Below you find a list of scientific abstracts on HGH
from pubmed.
|
|
| |
|
Endocrinology Section, National
Institute on Aging, National Institutes of Health, Baltimore,
Maryland.
In humans, both aging and GH
deficiency are associated with reduced protein synthesis,
decreased lean body and bone mass, and increased percent
body fat. In healthy individuals, spontaneous and
stimulated GH secretion, as well as circulating IGF-I
and IGFBP-3 levels, are significantly decreased with
advancing age. The extent to which these age-related
changes in GH and IGF-I contribute to alterations
in body composition and function remains to be elucidated.
GH treatment of GH-deficient adults or old men with
reduced IGF-I levels with exogenous GH increases plasma
IGF-I, nitrogen retention, and lean body mass, decreases
percent body fat, and exerts little effect on bone
mineral density. Short-term adverse effects of GH
therapy have been minimized by using low-dose regimens,
but it is still uncertain whether long-term GH supplementation
in adult life increases the risk of metabolic abnormalities
or malignancy. Administration of GHRH, which has been
shown to maintain the pattern of pulsatile GH secretion
in old men, may represent another possible physiological
approach to therapy. It may be justifiable initially
to limit use of GH to certain elderly patients such
as those suffering from catabolic illnesses, malnourishment,
burns, cachexia, etc. A great deal more research will
be necessary to determine whether normalization of
GH and IGF-I levels in healthy older persons will
lead to improvements in their physical and psychological
functional capacity and quality of life.
|
|
|
The influence of age on plasma
growth hormone (HGH) and cortisol response to i.v.
insulin (0.1 U/kg of body weight) was evaluated in
32 healthy subjects whose ages ranged between 20 and
84 years. A significant reduction in HGH response
to insulin was observed with aging. In the young (20-34
years), middel-aged (35-49 years), and elderly (53-84
years) groups, average HGH peaks were 46.51 +/- 7.37,
29.95 +/- 5.35, and 14.31 +/- 2.39 ng/ml while average
HGH areas were 2.911 +/- 0.484, 1.654 +/- 0.316, and
0.699 +/- 0.149 mug-min, respectively. Since insulin's
hypoglycemic effect became less rapid with aging,
this could, in part, explain the progressive decline
in the HGH response to insulin. This phenomen may
also be attributed to histological changes occurring
in the pituitary with aging. Moreover, cortisol response
was similar to all three age groups. These findings
suggest that, while HGH response to insulin is correlated
with age, adrenal response does not show any important
modifications with aging.
|
|
|
Research Centre for Endocrinology
and Metabolism, Sahlgrenska University Hospital, SE-413
45 Goteborg, Sweden.
GH replacement therapy in adults
with adult-onset GH deficiency (GHD) has been shown
to increase isometric and isokinetic muscle strength
in a few trials with limited numbers of patients.
In this single center, prospective, open-label study,
the effects of 5-yr GH replacement therapy on muscle
function were determined in 109 consecutive adults
(61 men and 48 women) with adult-onset GHD. The mean
initial GH dose was 0.88 mg/d. The dose was gradually
lowered, and after 5 yr the mean dose was 0.46 mg/d.
The mean IGF-I SD score increased from -1.54 at baseline
to 1.53 at study end. A sustained increase in lean
body mass and decrease in body fat was observed. The
GH treatment induced persistent increases in isometric
knee flexor strength, concentric knee flexor strength
at an angular velocity of 60 degrees/sec, and right-hand
peak grip strength. After correction for age and gender
using observed/predicted value ratios, a sustained
increase was also observed in isometric (60 degrees)
and concentric (180 degrees/sec) knee extensor strength,
average right-hand grip strength for 10 sec, and left-hand
grip strength. At study end, knee flexor and extensor
strength was 96-104% of predicted and hand grip strength
was 84-90% of predicted values. The local muscle endurance
was transiently decreased after correction for age
and gender. No gender difference was found in the
treatment responses in muscle strength. However, muscle
strength (also after correction for age and gender)
was lower in women than men throughout the study period.
In conclusion, GH replacement therapy in adults with
adult-onset GHD normalized isometric and isokinetic
knee flexor and extensor strength. Hand grip strength
increased but was not fully normalized.
|
|
|
Department of Endocrinology, Leiden
University Medical Center, The Netherlands.
Adults with GH deficiency (GHD)
suffer from muscle weakness, which can be caused by
the frequently reported decrease in muscle mass. However,
measurements of both muscle strength and mass of muscle
tested are scarce in adults with GHD. The aim of the
present study was, therefore, to investigate intrinsic
muscle strength (strength expressed per muscle volume
unit) in adults with GHD at baseline and after 52
weeks of recombinant human GH (rhGH) therapy given
in low, more physiological doses. A second objective
was to investigate the influence of GH on muscle bioenergetics
in the resting muscle. Isometric and isokinetic quadriceps
strengths were measured in 28 males with GHD and in
healthy controls matched for age and height. Quadriceps
mass, determined by magnetic resonance imaging, and
muscle bioenergetics, determined by phosphorus nuclear
magnetic resonance spectroscopy, were measured in
20 of 28 patients with GHD and in controls matched
for age and height. All patients were treated with
doses of rhGH ranging from 0.6-1.8 IU/day, given for
52 weeks. Measurements of muscle mass, strength, and
bioenergetics were repeated after 52 weeks of treatment
with rhGH. The mean GH dose at 52 weeks of rhGH treatment
was 1.3 +/- 0.8 IU/day. The mean serum insulin-like
growth factor I level at baseline was 9.4 +/- 0.7
nmol/L and significantly increased to 26.4 +/- 1.2
nmol/L after 52 weeks of rhGH treatment. Adults with
GHD had significantly reduced quadriceps muscle mass
(P = 0.034) and reduced isometric muscle strength
(P = 0.002) and tended to have low isokinetic muscle
strength (P = 0.06), which all improved after rhGH
therapy. Intrinsic muscle strength was not significantly
different in adults with GHD compared with that in
healthy controls and did not change during rhGH therapy.
No bioenergetic abnormalities at baseline or after
rhGH therapy were found in males with GHD. In conclusion,
quadriceps muscle mass is decreased in adults with
GHD and increased with rhGH therapy. These changes
in muscle mass account for the changes in muscle strength
found in these patients, as no changes in intrinsic
muscle strength were found.
|
|
|
Research Centre for Endocrinology
and Metabolism, Grona Straket 8, Sahlgrenska University
Hospital, SE-413 45 Goteborg, Sweden.
GH replacement therapy has
proved its efficacy and safety in short-term trials
and in a few long-term trials with limited number
of subjects. In this 1-center study, including 118
consecutive adults (70 men and 48 women; mean age,
49.3 yr; range, 22-74 yr) with adult-onset GH deficiency,
the effects of 5 yr of GH replacement on body composition,
bone mass, and metabolic indices were determined.
The mean initial GH dose was 0.98 mg/d. The dose was
gradually lowered, and after 5 yr the mean dose was
0.48 mg/d. The mean IGF-I SD score increased from
-1.73 at baseline to 1.66 at study end. A sustained
increase in lean body mass and a decrease in body
fat were observed. The GH treatment increased total
body bone mineral content as well as lumbar (L2-L4)
and femur neck bone mineral contents. BMD in lumbar
spine (L2-L4) and femur neck were increased and normalized
at study end. Total cholesterol and low density lipoprotein
cholesterol decreased, and high density lipoprotein
cholesterol increased. At 5 yr, serum concentrations
of triglycerides and hemoglobin A(1c) were reduced
compared with baseline values. The treatment responses
in IGF-I SD score, body fat as estimated by four-
and five-compartment body composition models, total
body protein and nitrogen, and lumbar bone mineral
content and BMD were more marked in men than in women.
One patient died during the period, four patients
discontinued the study due to adverse events, and
one dropped out due to lack of compliance. Four patients
were lost to follow-up. However, all patients were
retained in the statistical analysis according to
the intention to treat approach used. In conclusion,
5 yr of GH substitution in GH-deficient adults is
safe and well tolerated. The effects on body composition,
bone mass, and metabolic indices were sustained. The
effects on body composition and low density lipoprotein
cholesterol were seen after 1 yr, whereas the effects
on bone mass, triglycerides, and hemoglobin A(1c)
were first observed after years of treatment.
|
|
|
Department of Medicine, Medical
College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee.
BACKGROUND. The declining activity
of the growth hormone--insulin-like growth factor
I (IGF-I) axis with advancing age may contribute to
the decrease in lean body mass and the increase in
mass of adipose tissue that occur with aging. METHODS.
To test this hypothesis, we studied 21 healthy men
from 61 to 81 years old who had plasma IGF-I concentrations
of less than 350 U per liter during a six-month base-line
period and a six-month treatment period that followed.
During the treatment period, 12 men (group 1) received
approximately 0.03 mg of biosynthetic human growth
hormone per kilogram of body weight subcutaneously
three times a week, and 9 men (group 2) received no
treatment. Plasma IGF-I levels were measured monthly.
At the end of each period we measured lean body mass,
the mass of adipose tissue, skin thickness (epidermis
plus dermis), and bone density at nine skeletal sites.
RESULTS. In group 1, the mean plasma IGF-I level rose
into the youthful range of 500 to 1500 U per liter
during treatment, whereas in group 2 it remained below
350 U per liter. The administration of human growth
hormone for six months in group 1 was accompanied
by an 8.8 percent increase in lean body mass, a 14.4
percent decrease in adipose-tissue mass, and a 1.6
percent increase in average lumbar vertebral bone
density (P less than 0.05 in each instance). Skin
thickness increased 7.1 percent (P = 0.07). There
was no significant change in the bone density of the
radius or proximal femur. In group 2 there was no
significant change in lean body mass, the mass of
adipose tissue, skin thickness, or bone density during
treatment. CONCLUSIONS. Diminished secretion of growth
hormone is responsible in part for the decrease of
lean body mass, the expansion of adipose-tissue mass,
and the thinning of the skin that occur in old age.
|
|
|
Faculty of Life Sciences, Old Medical
School, University of Dundee, Scotland, UK.
This review examines the evidence
that growth hormone has metabolic effects in adult
human beings. The conclusion is that growth hormone
does indeed have powerful effects on fat and carbohydrate
metabolism, and in particular promotes the metabolic
use of adipose tissue triacylglycerol. However, there
is no proof that net protein retention is promoted
in adults, except possibly of connective tissue. The
overexaggeration of the effects of growth hormone
in muscle building is effectively promoting its abuse
and thereby encouraging athletes and elderly men to
expose themselves to increased risk of disease for
little benefit.
|
|
|
Schlosspark Clinic, Humboldt University,
Berlin, Germany.
Growth hormone (GH) secretion
in the elderly is generally diminished although there
are marked individual differences ranging from normal
GH secretion and normal levels of insulin-like growth
factor (IGF)-I through low GH and subnormal IGF-I.
It is assumed that the reduced central cholinergic
activity leading to unrestrained somatostatin release
leads to impaired GH secretion. The somatopause, if
it occurs at all, is, in contrast to the menopause,
a subtly developing physiological event. The menopause
often causes severe symptoms that justify hormone
replacement therapy, but the somatopause is a physiological
event at the end of the lifespan with no acute symptoms
that can be attributed to GH deficiency with certainty.
Whether the non-specific symptoms of old age, i.e.
truncal obesity, muscle atrophy, decreasing energy,
and mental disorders, can be--even partially--blamed
on decreased GH secretion is unclear. Thus, GH therapy
in elderly patients, in the absence of pituitary disease
cannot be recommended. In addition, the following
has to be considered: 1) GH has to be given by subcutaneous
injection, which may be technically difficult in elderly
patients. 2) It is difficult to find the right individual
dosage of GH since elderly patients may show increased
sensitivity to GH therapy (compared with children)
or may be GH-resistant. 3) Manifestation of diabetes
mellitus may be enhanced in elderly patients. 4) The
elevation of IGF-I levels may enhance the progression
of malignant disease; it has been shown that the concentration
of IGF-I in the circulation correlates to the frequency
of prostatic cancer. Furthermore, acromegalic patients
have a higher frequency of colonic polyps and gastrointestinal
malignancies. 5) Even if problems such as dosage,
mode of application and the questions of safety are
resolved, the present costs of GH therapy will not
allow to advocate GH treatment of all elderly patients
with low levels of IGF-I. However, since some patients
seem to benefit from GH therapy in senescence, further
studies are needed. There may be a subset of elderly
patients in whom GH treatment is useful. However,
unless these patients are included in a study protocol,
GH treatment should not be given to elderly patients
in the absence of pituitary disease.
|
|
|
Zentrum fur Geriatrie und Rehabilitation
am Burgerspital St. Gallen.
Human growth hormone is one
of the hormones used most frequently in the setting
of so-called anti-aging strategies. To date, the preventive
value of such a hormone replacement therapy in relatively
healthy and well functioning middle aged persons is
unknown. Although growth hormone leads to significant
alterations in body composition and changes in serum
cholesterol levels in patients with adult growth hormone
deficiency, there are currently no data supporting
the hypothesis that growth-hormone in non deficient
persons prolongs life span or reduces morbidity. Aging
is associated with a reduction of GH-secretion, serum
levels of insulin like growth factor I (IGF-I) and
alterations in body composition and function. Based
on the many clinical similarities between aging and
acquired growth hormone deficiency, several studies
have assessed the effects of growth hormone administration
in healthy aged women and men. Only a few studies
have addressed functional outcomes in a more frail
population. These studies suggest that a defined group
of older individuals with functional limitation might
benefit from GH as a strategy to prevent further functional
decline and delay nursing home admission. Because
of the lack of proof in frail patients, uncertain
long-term effects and high treatment costs GH-administration
in the aged should currently be restricted to research
questions. Future studies should address the question
whether growth hormone alone or in combination with
established strategies, such as exercise or improvement
in nutrition will serve as a measure to prevent functional
decline in frail geriatric patient populations.
|
|
|
Neuroendocrine Unit, Massachusetts
General Hospital, Boston 02114, USA.
BACKGROUND: Patients with adult-onset
growth hormone deficiency have reduced bone density
and increased fat mass. Growth hormone at high doses
may decrease body fat in these patients, but the effects
of growth hormone at more physiologic doses on bone
density and body composition have not been convincingly
shown. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether long-term growth
hormone therapy at a dose adjusted to maintain normal
insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) levels has clinical
effects in patients with adult-onset growth hormone
deficiency. DESIGN: Randomized, placebo-controlled
study. SETTING: Tertiary referral center. PATIENTS:
32 men with adult-onset growth hormone deficiency.
INTERVENTION: Growth hormone (initial daily dose,
10 micrograms/kg of body weight) or placebo for 18
months. The growth hormone dose was reduced by 25%
if IGF-1 levels were elevated. MEASUREMENTS: Body
composition and bone mineral density of the lumbar
spine, femoral neck, and proximal radius were measured
by dual energy x-ray absorptiometry at 6-month intervals.
Markers of bone turnover were also measured during
the first 12 months of the study. RESULTS: Growth
hormone therapy increased bone mineral density in
the lumbar spine by a mean (+/- SD) of 5.1% +/- 4.1%
and bone mineral density in the femoral neck by 2.4%
+/- 3.5%. In the growth hormone group, significant
increases were seen in the following markers of bone
turnover: osteocalcin (4.4 +/- 3.6 mg/L to 7.2 +/-
4.6 mg/L) and urinary pyridinoline (39.0 +/- 19.8
nmol/mmol of creatinine to 55.7 +/- 25.5 nmol/mmol
of creatinine) and deoxypyridinoline (8.4 +/- 7.1
nmol/mmol of creatinine to 14.9 +/- 9.4 nmol/mmol
of creatinine). Percentage of body fat in the growth
hormone group decreased (from 31.9% +/- 6.5% to 28.3%
+/- 7.0%), and lean body mass increased (from 59.0
+/- 8.5 kg to 61.5 +/- 6.9 kg). These changes were
significant compared with corresponding changes in
the placebo group (P < 0.01 for all comparisons).
CONCLUSIONS: Growth hormone administered to men with
adult-onset growth hormone deficiency at a dose adjusted
according to serum IGF-1 levels increases bone density
and stimulates bone turnover, decreases body fat and
increases lean mass, and is associated with a low
incidence of side effects.
|
|
|
Medical Service, V.A. Medical Center,
Palo Alto, California 94305.
Growth hormone (GH) secretion
declines during normal aging, resulting in lower serum
insulin-like growth factor (IGF)-I levels. It has
been proposed that many of the catabolic changes seen
in normal aging, including osteoporosis and muscle
atrophy, are in part caused by the decreased action
of the GH-IGF-I axis. In addition, patients with GH
deficiency have increased overall cardiovascular mortality.
Several investigators have initiated GH treatment
for elderly patients with relative hyposomatotropinemia.
Initial reports suggest that GH can increase muscle
mass, improve exercise tolerance, increase REM sleep
and cause an enhanced sense of well-being. The basis
for neuropsychiatric changes during GH therapy may
be due to a direct CNS action of GH itself, to the
increased IGF-I secretion which GH elicits, or to
enhanced functioning of peripheral organ systems.
Long-term studies will determine whether GH or IGF-I
can exert a neurotrophic action in the aging brain.
|
|
|
Department of Endocrinology, Christie
Hospital NHS Trust, Withington, Manchester, UK.
Organic growth hormone (GH)
deficiency in adults results in many adverse changes
similar to the changes which occur in humans with
increasing age. The secretion of GH from the anterior
pituitary declines with increasing age. This observation,
together with the changes in body composition associated
with organic GH deficiency in adults, has led to the
suggestion that the elderly without hypothalamic-pituitary
disease are GH deficient and may benefit from GH therapy.
The impact of organic disease of the hypothalamic-pituitary
axis in the elderly may result in a reduction in GH
secretion of up to 90%. This reduction in GH secretion
is sufficient to cause a fall in the serum insulin-like
growth factor-1 (IGF-1) concentration, abnormal body
composition and abnormal bone turnover, although bone
mineral density is unaffected. These changes are distinct
from those associated with the hyposomatotropism of
the elderly, but are less severe than those seen in
younger adults with organic GH deficiency. In this
chapter we discuss the effects of organic GH deficiency
in elderly subjects and the potential effects of GH
replacement therapy. We also examine the potential
for GH therapy to correct some of the detrimental
effects of the ageing process.
|
|
|
The Maine Center for Osteoporosis
Research and Education, St. Joseph Hospital, Bangor
04401, USA.
Aging is associated with a
significant decline in secretion of growth hormone.
This in turn leads to reduced circulating IGF-I and
changes in IGF-binding proteins. Growth hormone replacement
to growth hormone-deficient individuals has been shown
to improve quality of life, enhance bone and muscle
mass, and reduce cardiovascular risk. However, studies
with growth hormone therapy in the elderly have been
somewhat disappointing with minimal changes in lean
body mass, musculoskeletal function, and overall quality
of life. Moreover, recent evidence suggests that high
normal serum IGF-I levels may be associated with a
greater risk of several neoplastic disorders. Hence,
there is less enthusiasm for reversing the changes
of the "somatopause" with recombinant growth
factors. An overview of these issues and the prospects
for the future will be discussed in this article.
|
|
|
Department of Internal Medicine
and Gerontology, Hopital Charles Foix (Assistance Publique-Hopitaux
de Paris), Ivry-sur-Seine, France.
The aims of this review are
to present a brief overview of growth hormone (GH)
physiology and to summarize the studies of GH treatment
in adults. Special attention has been paid to randomized
controlled trials. Studies have revealed a partial
deficiency of GH secretion in the elderly. GH secretion
on the average declines by 14% with each decade in
normal adults after 20 years of age. Aging has a central
effect on the GH secretion and peripheric effect on
insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) through changes
in the body composition. GH administration may attenuate
several important decrements in body composition and
in function associated with aging. GH may also have
very potent anabolic effects in surgical situations.
Short-term side-effects of GH therapy include edema,
carpal tunnel syndrome and arthralgia. A number of
agents such as oral GH-releasing peptides (GHRPs)
increase GH secretion; they may be an alternative
to GH treatment in the future. Further studies of
GH replacement are needed, examining issues such as
dosage, tolerance and efficacy before the widespread
use of GH in the elderly is advocated.
|
|
|
DISEM, Cattedra di Endocrinologia,
University of Genova, Italy.
In aging, both changes in body
composition and a decrease in GH secretion are observed.
While recombinant human GH (rhGH) therapy was shown
to be effective in GH-deficient adults, its effects
on normal aging are controversial. This study addressed
the effects of six-month administration of low dosages
of rhGH in a group of 5 healthy elderly subjects (age
range 71-86 years). All subjects received 2 IU rhGH
(Saizen, Serono) x 2/week s.c., which was approximately
0.03 mg/kg/week, and were examined before and 1, 3,
and 6 months after the start of the therapy, as well
as 3 months after therapy was suspended. Hormonal,
metabolic and biochemical parameters, as well as bone
density at the forearm level, body composition and
muscle strength, assessed by isokinetic exercises,
were evaluated at each scheduled visit. After the
start of the therapy, there was an average 9 +/- 3%
increase (median 8%) in IGF-I levels (IGF-I basal:
145.6 +/- 9 ng/mL, IGF-I peak: 176.0 +/- 10; p <
0.001). An increase in lean body weight, a decrease
in fat (p < 0.05), and an improvement in muscle
strength (p < 0.01) were recorded. No significant
variation was observed in the metabolic parameters.
During rhGH therapy, an increase in both bone resorption
and formation parameters, and a slightly decreasing
trend in bone density were noted. In conclusion, low
dosages of rhGH in healthy elderly subjects seem to
determine some physiological effects, such as a slight
increase in IGF-I levels, which in turn may be responsible
for the positive effects on body mass composition
and muscle strength, without producing side effects.
On the other hand, 6-month subcutaneous rhGH therapy
at the dosage employed was unable to improve bone
density.
|
|
|
Garvan Institute of Medical Research,
St. Vincent's Hospital, Sydney, Australia.
Detailed studies of the ontogeny
of growth hormone (GH) secretion have shown unequivocally
that GH is produced throughout life but secretion
declines progressively to about 20% of that in puberty.
These changes are accounted for in part by changes
in central neuro-endocrine function, nutritional factors
and by changes in sex steroid milieu. Mean 24-hour
GH concentrations in the normal elderly are frequently
below the limit of assay detectability where values
are indistinguishable from matched adults with organic
GH deficiency. The notion that diminished GH action
may account for the undesirable changes in body composition
and function in the elderly is supported by beneficial
findings of GH treatment in GH-deficient adults. Preliminary
results of GH treatment in the normal elderly suggest
beneficial effects on body composition but a high
incidence of side-effects. Questions addressing cost,
benefit, dosage, safety and tolerance need to be critically
addressed before GH can be considered for use in the
aging.
|
|
| |
| |
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|