PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND AGING.
EXPERIMENTAL AND CLINICAL DATA.
PROFESSIONAL SPORT: NEGATIVE ASPECTS
INTRODUCTION
Professional sport
has always been opposed to moderate exercise in terms
of the effects it has on the health of a person engaged
in
it. Although there are many different reasons for the bad reputation
ascribed to professional sport, the main factors are exhaustion,
routine physical activity patterns, and the injuries-related
factors (both
extrinsic and intrinsic). Let’s consider them step by step.
Exhaustion. Professional sport is necessarily connected to the level
of physical activity that tends to, and in most cases does exceeds,
the natural ability of a human organism to successfully overcome both
the external and internal pressures.
Thus, heat exhaustion is said to be one of the major causes of death
of American football players. According to a North Carolina study,
eighteen high school and college players have died from heat exhaustion
just since 1995.
Many sportsmen are struck down in their youth due to the heart-related
problems. Tremendous levels of physical activity force the heart of
a sportsman to work like a pump, which leads to partially irreversible
left ventricular hypertrophy with impaired left ventricular diastolic
filling.
Routine physical activity patterns. Most of the modern fitness specialists
agree that in order to keep oneself in a good shape without harming
one’s health, a person has to do exercise that is fun and various.
In contrast, when a person is engaged in professional sport, the same
movement patterns that are repeated during a long period of time lead
to “professional” illnesses that usually are typical
for a particular sport.
Thus, professional golfers usually suffer from kidney-related problems,
and baseball players end up with problems with thoracic vertebras and
neck-bone. Tennis tends to impair the functions of the muscles, which
leads to pleurisy, and so on. Another example concerning tennis is
severe neurological injury called the N. suprascapularis. The studies
show that this injury is reversible if the diagnosis is established
early on and if the hurting movement is avoided until full recovery.
It is proved that some certain movements are necessary in order to
counter the typical movements that cause injuries. In this case, the
study suggests that a backhand stroke done with both arms can have
a protective effect against this pathology.
The last, but not the least, is the injuries-prone nature of most of
the kinds of professional sport. There are various risk factors that
are said to be responsible for such a high level of injuries in professional
sport. Among the extrinsic risk factors are: excessive load on the
body, including the number of repetitions, the speed of movement, etc.,
lack of enforcement of the safety rules, training errors, and so on.
The intrinsic risk factors are, for example, muscle imbalance and joint
laxity.
Some sports are considered to be safer than the others. However,
it is difficult to find a sport that is completely safe when it is
done
at a professional level. Thus, football is often opposed to rugby
as a safer alternative. However, for example in England neurologists
called
for football players to start wearing helmets similar to those used
by professional rugby players. The calls were prompted by a coroner's
finding that one of the England’s leading football players
had died from degenerative brain damage caused by heading balls.
Although sport medicine professionals are in a constant search for
the measures that can make professional sport safer, to date it still
significantly damages the health of those who decide to pursue the
career of professional sportsmen. For some particular studies that
show how exactly professional sport can harm one’s health,
please see the extracts below (35 extracts total).
Echocardiographic
findings in 104 professional cyclists with follow-up study. Miki T, Yokota Y, Seo T, Yokoyama
M. First Department of Internal Medicine, Kobe University
School of Medicine, Japan. Am Heart J. 1994 Apr;127(4 Pt 1):898-905
To assess the effect of long-term
athletic training on the heart, 104 professional cyclists
and 40 sedentary controls
(69 younger cyclists and 26 controls aged 20 to 39 and
35 older cyclists and 14 controls aged 40 to 60) were examined
by using M-mode and pulsed Doppler echocardiography. Cyclists
had larger and more hypertrophied left ventricle than did
controls (p < 0.001) and had normal percentages of fractional
shortening (%FS). The ratio of left ventricular late-to-early
diastolic peak filling velocity (A/R) of younger cyclists
was normal, but the A/R of older cyclists was larger than
that of controls (p < 0.001). Of the 104 cyclists, 95
continued cycling and were reexamined 2 years later; 9
of 40 older cyclists retired and were reexamined 20 +/-
8 months after retirement. During the follow-up period
for the active cyclists, left ventricular dilatation, hypertrophy,
and %FS of both younger and older cyclists and the A/R
of younger cyclists did not change. However, the A/R of
older cyclists increased (p < 0.01). For the nine retired
cyclists, left ventricular dimension decreased (p < 0.001),
left ventricular wall thickness and %FS did not change,
and A/R increased (p < 0.05) after retirement. We concluded
that (1) cyclists had large and hypertrophied left ventricles
with normal systolic function, and (2) some cyclists with
long-term athletic training may have partly irreversible
left ventricular hypertrophy with impaired left ventricular
diastolic filling.
Vascular and cardiac remodeling in world
class professional cyclists. Abergel E, Linhart A, Chatellier
G, Gariepy J, Ducardonnet A, Diebold B, Menard J. Centre de Medecine Preventive Cardio-vasculaire,
Service d'Informatique Medicale, Institut Coeur Effort Sante, Hopital
Broussais, Paris, France. Am Heart J. 1998 Nov;136(5):818-23
BACKGROUND: Numerous studies have
demonstrated that left ventricular (LV) hypertrophy
is often associated with conditioning.
METHODS AND RESULTS: The aim of the study was to evaluate
cardiac and carotid artery changes induced by professional
cycling. We collected M-mode left ventricle and B-mode
right common carotid artery data from 149 male professional
cyclists before the 1995 "Tour de France" race
and 52 male control subjects. LV mass indexed to body surface
area in cyclists was double that in control subjects, with
no overlap of 95% confidence intervals (cyclists 100.9
to 187 g/m2 and control subjects 51.8 to 96.3 g/m2). Both
mean arterial diameter and mean arterial diastolic intima-media
thickness (IMT) were 13% higher in cyclists than in control
subjects, with overlap of 95% confidence intervals (for
arterial IMT 0.45 to 0.65 mm in cyclists and 0.38 to 0.60
mm in control subjects). CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest
that intense cycling has an effect on the cardiovascular
system, more pronounced on the left ventricle and less
pronounced on large arteries. Nevertheless, athletic training
should be considered as a potential determinant of carotid
modification.
Effect of detraining on the cardiopulmonary
reflex in professional runners and hammer throwers. Giannattasio
C, Seravalle G, Cattaneo BM, Cuspidi C, Sampieri L, Bolla
GB, Grassi G, Mancia G. Cattedra di Medicina Interna, Universita
di Milano, Italy. Am J Cardiol. 1992 Mar 1;69(6):677-80
In professional athletes with marked cardiac hypertrophy,
reflex influences originating from cardiopulmonary receptors
are impaired. To determine whether the reflex is restored
after termination of physical training and regression of
cardiac hypertrophy 8 former athletes (age 31 +/- 6 years,
mean +/- SD) who stopped agonistic activity for 5 +/- 1
years were compared with 15 sedentary subjects (27 +/-
7 years) and 19 active professional athletes (22 +/- 7
years). Cardiopulmonary receptor stimulation and deactivation
were obtained by increasing and reducing left ventricular
end-diastolic diameter (echocardiography) through leg raising
and nonhypotensive lower body negative pressure, respectively.
Left ventricular mass index (echocardiography) was markedly
and significantly (p less than 0.01) greater in athletes
(135 +/- 6 g/m2) than in former athletes (105 +/- 4 g/m2)
whose value was similar to that of sedentary subjects (98
+/- 4 g/m2). The reduction in forearm vascular resistance
and plasma norepinephrine induced by increasing left ventricular
end-diastolic diameter was 24 and 23% less in athletes
than in former athletes whose responses were similar to
those of sedentary subjects. This was the case also for
the responses induced by reducing left ventricular end-diastolic
diameter. In contrast, the hemodynamic responses to cold
pressor test were similar in the 3 groups. It is concluded
that the impairment of the cardiopulmonary reflex observed
in athletes is largely reversible when physical training
is terminated. This may be due to regression of left ventricular
hypertrophy.
Neuropsychological impairment in soccer
athletes. Downs DS, Abwender D. Department of Exercise and Sport
Sciences, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida 32611-8205,
USA. J Sports Med Phys Fitness. 2002 Mar;42(1):103-7
BACKGROUND: Soccer reportedly places participants at risk
for neuropsychological impairment, although it is unknown
if the risk is associated primarily with concussion, subconcussive
blows from heading the ball, or some combination thereof.
Moreover, the extent to which younger versus older athletes
are at risk for soccer-related cognitive impairment is
unclear. We hypothesized that soccer athletes, especially
older ones, would show poorer neuropsychological test performance
than comparable swimmers. METHODS: Thirty-two soccer (26
college and 6 professional) and 29 swimmers (22 college
and 7 masters level), all involved for at least 4 years
in their sport at collegiate or national levels, participated.
In a 2 X 2 (sport X age category) factorial design, all
participants underwent 4 neuropsychological tests with
11 outcome measures assessing motor speed, attention, concentration,
reaction time, and conceptual thinking. RESULTS: Soccer
athletes performed worse than swimmers on measures of conceptual
thinking. The older soccer group in particular performed
poorly on measures of conceptual thinking, reaction time,
and concentration. Among non-goaltender soccer athletes,
estimates of career exposure to brain trauma (based on
length of career and level of play) predicted significantly
poorer test performance on 6 of 11 measures, even after
statistically controlling for age. CONCLUSIONS: Results
provide additional evidence that participation in soccer
may be associated with poorer neuropsychological performance,
although the observed pattern of findings does not specifically
implicate heading as the cause. Although deficits were
most apparent among older soccer players, serial neuropsychological
testing for early detection of impairment is recommended
for younger players as well.
Ex-professional association footballers
have an increased prevalence of osteoarthritis of the hip
compared with age matched controls despite not having sustained
notable hip injuries. Shepard GJ, Banks AJ, Ryan WG. Royal Bolton Hospital, Minerva
Road, Farnworth, Bolton, Lancashire, UK. Br J Sports Med. 2003 Feb;37(1):80-1
OBJECTIVE: To compare the prevalence of self reported,
physician diagnosed osteoarthritis (OA) of the hip in ex-professional
footballers with that in age matched controls in the general
public. METHOD: A questionnaire was sent to the 92 football
league and premiership managers to assess the prevalence
of OA of various joints. The prevalence of OA of the hip
in those managers that were ex-professional footballers
was assessed. Radiographic controls were obtained and used
to assess the prevalence of OA of the hip in the general
population. The results of the two groups were compared
statistically using chi(2) tabulation. RESULTS: Seventy
four (80%) of the managers responded to the questionnaire.
Nine of the 68 ex-professional footballers who replied
had OA of the hip, and six of these had undergone a total
of eight total hip replacements. Of the 18 managers who
did not respond, 12 were known to be ex-professionals.
In the control group of 136, two had OA of the hip. The
two groups differed significantly (p<0.001). The odds
ratio for OA of the hip was 10.2 (95% confidence interval
2.1 to 48.8). CONCLUSION: The ex-professional footballers
had a significantly higher prevalence of OA of the hip
than an age matched group of radiographic controls.
The role of hip arthroscopy in the elite
athlete. McCarthy J, Barsoum W, Puri L, Lee JA, Murphy S,
Cooke P. Department of Radiology, New England Baptist Hospital,
125 Parker Hill Avenue, Boston, MA 02120-1636, USA. Clin Orthop. 2003 Jan;(406):71-4
Intraarticular hip disorders in the elite athlete are
a relatively rare but serious potential consequence of
high-level competition. Axial and torsional forces involving
the hips of elite athletes place them at potentially higher
risk for chondral injuries, labral injuries, or both. Ten
patients (13 hips) had arthroscopy. Of the 10 patients,
the average age was 24 years. Nine patients were men and
one was a woman. Of the 13 (10 patients) arthroscopies
done two cases were bilateral, and one patient had the
same hip operated on twice. Seven of the patients were
professional hockey players, one patient was a football
player, one patient was a baseball player, and one patient
was a golfer. All 13 hips (10 patients) had anterior labral
tears, whereas two hips had anterior and posterior labral
tears. Two hips had an average of four loose bodies, four
had evidence of chondral lesions, and one had an anterior
margin acetabular fracture. Twelve of 13 arthroscopies
were successful; however, one patient had recurrent symptoms.
There were no surgical complications. Hip arthroscopy is
a safe and reproducible method to diagnose and treat intraarticular
hip disorders in athletes, which facilitates earlier return
to their respective sport.
Imaging of hip disorders in athletes. Bencardino
JT, Palmer WE. Division of Bone and Joint Radiology,
Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston 02114, USA. Radiol Clin North Am. 2002 Mar;40(2):267-87, vi-vii.
Normal hip joint function is fundamental in running-,
jumping-, and kicking-based sporting activities. Hip disorders
do not account for a large portion of exercise-related
injuries, but they can pose a clinical dilemma since symptoms
tend to be non-specific. Conventional radiographs may demonstrate
some causes of hip pain, such as stress fractures and degenerative
joint disease. Magnetic resonance (MR) imaging of the hip
has proven valuable in the diagnosis of radiographically
occult osseous abnormalities and periarticular soft tissue
disorders such as stress fractures, avulsion injuries,
musculotendinous abnormalities, and bursitis. Conventional
MR imaging has been less useful in the evaluation of intra-articular
lesions including acetabular labral tears, intra-articular
loose bodies, and cartilage lesions. The visualization
of intra-articular structures and their abnormalities can
be improved by the injection of diluted Gadolinium, which
distends the capsule and leaks into labral tears. This
article will focus on the use of conventional radiography
and MR imaging in recreational and professional athletes
with painful hip joints, and where possible it will compare
MR imaging with other diagnostic modalities such as bone
scan and CT.
[Paralysis of the suprascapular nerve
and tennis. Apropos of 3 groups of professional players]
[Article
in French] Daubinet G, Rodineau J. Hopitaux de Paris. Schweiz Z Sportmed. 1991 Sep;39(3):113-8. French
A recent surge of interest for tennis has given rise to
an increased incidence of injuries to the N. suprascapularis.
The early symptoms of this pathology are often missed,
leading subsequently to a chronic condition, including
an irreversible trauma to the nerve. Nevertheless, through
the study of three groups of professional tournament players,
we were able to show that the neurological injury is reversible
if the diagnosis is established early on and if the hurting
movement is avoided until full recovery. A backhand stroke
done with both arms seems to have a protective effect against
this pathology.
[Effect of intensive physical loads
on renal function]
[Article in Russian] Bukaev IuN, Gusev BS, Darenkov AF,
Makarova TI, Vladimirova NN. Urol Nefrol (Mosk). 1989 Mar-Apr;(2):3-7. Russian
The purpose of the study was to
evaluate the extent of renal functional disorders, developing
in response to muscular
exercise of varying intensity and duration in 64 professional
athletes, aged 17 to 26 years. Comparative characteristics
of 131I-hippuran kinetics through the urinary tract both
at rest and after "acute" (single) and chronic
(many years') physical exercise are obtained. There was
a direct relationship between effective renal blood flow
and the magnitude of muscular exercise. It is demonstrated
that post-exercise renal changes disappear without trace,
while individuals, exposed to extreme muscular stress for
long periods of time, i.e. the professional athletes, may
develop irreversible functional changes. Impaired renal
function can hardly be attributed to the emergence of yet
another compensatory mechanism, for such notions as 'compensation'
and "persistent impairement of functional potentials
of an organ" are mutually exclusive.
Incidence of injury in semi-professional
rugby league players. Gabbett TJ. Queensland Academy of Sport, PO Box 8103, Wooloongabba,
Queensland 4102, Australia. Br J Sports Med. 2003 Feb;37(1):36-43; discussion 43-4
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the site, nature, cause, and
severity of injuries in semi-professional rugby league
players. METHODS: The incidence of injury was prospectively
studied in one hundred and fifty six semi-professional
rugby league players over two competitive seasons. All
injuries sustained during matches and training sessions
were recorded. Injury data were collected from a total
of 137 matches and 148 training sessions. Information recorded
included the date and time of injury, site, nature, cause,
and severity of injury. RESULTS: During the two seasons,
1,694 playing injuries and 559 training injuries were sustained.
The match injury incidence was 824.7 per 1,000 player-position
game hours and training injury incidence was 45.3 per 1,000
training hours. Over 20% of the total training (17.4 per
1,000) and playing (168.0 per 1,000) injuries sustained
were to the thigh and calf. Muscular injuries (haematomas
and strains) were the most common type of injury sustained
during training (22.0 per 1,000, 48.7%) and matches (271.7
per 1,000, 32.9%). Playing injuries were most commonly
sustained in tackles (382.2 per 1,000, 46.3%), while overexertion
was the most common cause of training injuries (15.5 per
1,000, 34.4%). The majority of playing injuries were sustained
in the first half of matches (1,013.6 per 1,000, 61.5%
v 635.8 per 1,000, 38.5%), whereas training injuries occurred
more frequently in the latter stages of the training session
(50.0 per 1,000, 55.3% v 40.5 per 1,000, 44.7%). Significantly
more training injuries were sustained in the early half
of the season, however, playing injuries occurred more
frequently in the latter stages of the season. CONCLUSIONS:
These results suggest that changes in training and playing
intensity impact significantly upon injury rates in semi-professional
rugby league players. Further studies investigating the
influence of training and playing intensity on injuries
in rugby league are warranted.
Common rugby league injuries. Recommendations
for treatment and preventative measures. Gibbs N. South Sydney Orthopaedic and Sports Medicine Centre,
Maroubra, New South Wales, Australia. Sports Med. 1994 Dec;18(6):438-50.
Rugby league is the main professional team sport played
in Eastern Australia. It is also very popular at a junior
and amateur level. However, injuries are common because
of the amount of body contact that occurs and the amount
of running that is required to participate in the game.
Injuries to the lower limbs account for over 50% of all
injuries. The most common specific injuries are ankle lateral
ligament tears, knee medial collateral and anterior cruciate
ligament tears, groin musculotendinous tears, hamstring
and calf muscle tears, and quadriceps muscle contusions.
Head injuries are common and consist of varying degrees
of concussion as well as lacerations and facial fractures.
Serious head injury is rare. Some of the more common upper
limb injuries are to the acromioclavicular and glenohumeral
joints. Accurate diagnosis of these common injuries using
appropriate history, examination and investigations is
critical in organising a treatment and rehabilitation plan
that will return the player to competition as soon as possible.
An understanding of the mechanism of injury is also important
in order to develop preventative strategies.
Increased diffusion in the brain of
professional boxers: a preclinical sign of traumatic brain
injury? Zhang L, Ravdin LD, Relkin N, Zimmerman RD, Jordan
B, Lathan WE, Ulug AM. Department of Radiology, Weill Medical
College of Cornell University, New York, NY 10021, USA. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2003 Jan;24(1):52-7
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Professional
boxing is associated with chronic, repetitive head blows
that may cause brain
injuries. Diffusion-weighted imaging is sensitive to microscopic
changes and may be a useful tool to quantify the microstructural
integrity of the brain. In this study, we sought to quantify
microscopic alterations associated with chronic traumatic
brain injury in professional boxers. METHODS: MR and diffusion-weighted
imaging were performed in 24 boxers and in 14 age- and
sex-matched control subjects with no history of head trauma.
Using distribution analysis, the average diffusion constant
of the entire brain (BD(av)) and diffusion distribution
width (sigma) were calculated for each subject; findings
in professional boxers were compared with those of control
subjects. In the boxer group, correlations between diffusion
changes and boxing history and diffusion changes and MR
imaging findings were assessed. RESULTS: The measured diffusion
values in the boxer group were significantly higher than
those measured in the control group (BD(av), P <.0001;
sigma, P <.01). In the boxer group, a robust correlation
was found between increased BD(av) and frequency of hospitalization
for boxing injuries (r = 0.654, P <.05). The most common
MR finding in the boxer group was volume loss inappropriate
to age followed by cavum septum pellucidum, subcortical
white matter disease, and periventricular white matter
disease. CONCLUSION: Boxers had higher diffusion constants
than those in control subjects. Our data suggest that microstructural
damage of the brain associated with chronic traumatic brain
injury may elevate whole-brain diffusion. This global elevation
can exist even when routine MR findings are normal.
Injuries among
world-class professional beach volleyball players. The
Federation Internationale de Volleyball beach volleyball
injury study. Bahr R, Reeser JC;
Federation Internationale de Volleyball. Oslo Sports Trauma
Research Center, University of Sport and Physical Education,
Oslo, Norway. Am J Sports Med. 2003 Jan-Feb;31(1):119-25
BACKGROUND: Very little is known
about the injury characteristics of beach volleyball.
PURPOSE: To describe the incidence
and pattern of injuries among professional male and female
beach volleyball players. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study--retrospective
injury recall and prospective registration. METHODS: Injuries
occurring over a 7.5-week interval of the summer season
were retrospectively registered by interviewing 178 of
the 188 participating players (95%) in the 2001 Beach Volleyball
World Championships. Injuries were also cataloged prospectively
during five of the tournaments held during this interval.
RESULTS: Fifty-four acute injuries was recorded, of which
23 (43%) resulted in 1 or more days of missed practice
or competition. The incidence of acute time-loss injuries
was estimated to be 3.1 per 1000 competition hours and
0.8 per 1000 training hours. Knee (30%), ankle (17%), and
finger injuries (17%) accounted for more than half of all
acute time-loss injuries. In addition, 67 players reported
79 overuse injuries for which they received medical attention
during the study period. The three most common overuse
conditions were low back pain (19%), knee pain (12%), and
shoulder problems (10%). Similar results were observed
in the prospective portion of the study. CONCLUSIONS: The
rate of acute time-loss injuries in beach volleyball is
considerably lower than that in most other team sports,
but overuse injuries affecting the low back, knees, and
shoulder represent a significant source of disability and
impaired performance for professional beach volleyball
players. Copyright 2003 American Orthopaedic Society for
Sports Medicine.
Stress fractures in athletes: review
of 196 cases. Iwamoto J, Takeda T. Department of Sports Medicine, Keio
University School of Medicine, 35 Shinanomachi, Shinjuku-ku,
Tokyo 160-8582,
Japan. J Orthop Sci. 2003;8(3):273-8
The purpose of this study was to investigate the association
of stress fractures with age, sex, sport level, sporting
activity, and skeletal site in athletes seen at our sports
medicine clinic between September 1991 and May 2001. During
these 10 years, 10 726 patients (6415 males, 3861 females)
visited our clinic because of sport-related injuries, and
196 patients [125 males (1.9%), 71 females (1.8%)] sustained
stress fractures. The average age of the patients with
stress fractures was 20.1 years (range 10-46 years); 84
patients (42.6%) were 15-19 years of age, and 68 (34.7%)
were 20-24 years of age. Altogether, 74 patients (37.8%)
were active at the high recreational level and 122 (62.2%)
at the competitive level. The sites of the stress fractures
varied from sport to sport. The ulnar olecranon was the
most common stress fracture site among baseball athletes
and the rib among the rowing athletes. Classical ballet,
aerobics, tennis, and volleyball athletes predominantly
sustained stress fractures of the tibial shaft. Basketball
athletes predominantly sustained stress fractures of the
tibial shaft and medial malleolus and the metatarsal bone,
whereas track and field and soccer athletes predominantly
sustained stress fractures of the tibial shaft and pubic
bone. Our results show that stress fractures are seen even
in high-level adolescent athletes, with similar proportions
for males and females, and that particular sports are associated
with specific sites for stress fractures.
A 7-year study on risks and costs of
knee injuries in male and female youth participants in 12
sports. de Loes M, Dahlstedt LJ, Thomee R. Institute of Research in
Sports Sciences, Swiss School of Sports, Macolin. Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2000 Apr;10(2):90-7
Knee injuries are common and account
in various sports for 15-50% of all sports injuries.
The cost of knee injuries
is therefore a large part of the cost for medical care
of sports injuries. Furthermore, the risk of acquiring
a knee injury during sports is considered higher for females
than for males. The nationwide organization "Youth
and Sports" represents the major source of organized
sports and recreation for Swiss youth and engages annually
around 370000 participants in the age group of 14 to 20
years. The purpose of this study was to combine data on
knee injuries from two sources, the first being data on
the exposure to risk found in the activity registration
in "Youth and Sports" and the second injuries
with their associated costs resulting from the activities
and filed at the Swiss Military Insurance. This allowed
calculation of knee injury incidences, to compare risks
between males and females and to estimate the costs of
medical treatment. The study comprises 3864 knee injuries
from 12 sports during 7 years. Females were significantly
more at risk in six sports: alpinism, downhill skiing,
gymnastics, volleyball, basketball and team handball. The
incidences of knee injuries and of cruciate ligament injuries
in particular, together with the costs per hour of participation,
all displayed the same sports as the top five for both
females and males: ice hockey, team handball, soccer, downhill
skiing and basketball. Female alpinism and gymnastics had
also high rankings. Knee injuries comprised 10% of all
injuries in males and 13% in females, but their proportional
contribution to the costs per hour of participation was
27% and 33%, respectively. From this study it can be concluded
that females were significantly more at risk for knee injuries
than males in six sports and that knee injuries accounted
for a high proportion of the costs of medical treatment.
Gender differences in muscular protection
of the knee in torsion in size-matched athletes. Wojtys EM,
Huston LJ, Schock HJ, Boylan JP, Ashton-Miller JA. University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, USA. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2003 May;85-A(5):782-9
BACKGROUND: Female athletes who participate in sports
involving jumping and cutting maneuvers are up to eight
times more likely to sustain a rupture of the anterior
cruciate ligament than are men participating in the same
sports. We tested the hypothesis that healthy young women
are able to volitionally increase the apparent torsional
stiffness of the knee, by maximally activating the knee
muscles, significantly less than are size-matched men participating
in the same type of sport. METHODS: Twenty-four NCAA (National
Collegiate Athletic Association) Division-I athletes (twelve
men and twelve women) competing in sports associated with
a high risk of injury to the anterior cruciate ligament
(basketball, volleyball, and soccer) were compared with
twenty-eight collegiate endurance athletes (fourteen men
and fourteen women) participating in sports associated
with a low risk of such injuries (bicycling, crew, and
running). Male and female pairs were matched for age, height,
weight, body mass index, shoe size, and activity level.
Testing was performed with a weighted pendulum that applied
a medially directed 80-N impulse force to the lateral aspect
of the right forefoot. The resulting internal rotation
of the leg was measured optically, to the nearest 0.25
degrees, at 30 degrees and 60 degrees of knee flexion,
both with and without maximal activation of the knee muscles.
RESULTS: Maximal rotations of the leg were greater in women
than in men in both the passive and the active muscle state
(16% and 27% greater [p = 0.01 and p = 0.02], respectively).
Moreover, female athletes exhibited a significantly (18%)
smaller volitional increase in apparent torsional stiffness
of the knee under internal rotation loading than did the
matched male athletes (p = 0.014); this was particularly
the case for those who participated in sports involving
jumping and pivoting maneuvers (42% difference between
genders, p = 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: The collegiate female
athletes involved in high-risk sports exhibited less muscular
protection of the knee ligaments during external loading
of the knee than did size and sport-matched male athletes.
The prevalence of chronic knee injury
in triathletes. Clements K, Yates B, Curran M. University College Northampton,
Nene Centre for Healthcare Education, United Kingdom. Br J Sports Med. 1999 Jun;33(3):214-6
OBJECTIVES: To add to the area of
triathlon research by providing much needed prevalence
data on knee injury in
triathletes. METHOD: An incidental "in field" sampling
technique was used to interview 58 triathletes aged between
15 and 55 years about knee injury during a triathlon event.
The sample comprised 46 men and 12 women. RESULTS: Most
knee injuries occurred during the running event (72%) and
affected the lateral side of the knee (38%). In all, 78%
of the sample sought treatment from a healthcare professional.
CONCLUSION: The study has provided much needed prevalence
data on chronic knee injury in triathletes.
Prevention and treatment of common eye
injuries in sports. Rodriguez JO, Lavina AM, Agarwal A. Department of Family
Medicine, East Carolina University/Brody School of Medicine,
Greenville, North Carolina, 27858-5434,
USA. Am Fam Physician. 2003 Apr 1;67(7):1481-8
Sports have become increasingly popular and account for
numerous eye injuries each year. The sports that most commonly
cause eye injuries, in order of decreasing frequency, are
basketball, water sports, baseball, and racquet sports.
Sports are classified as low risk, high risk, and very
high risk. Sports-related eye injuries are blunt, penetrating,
and radiation injuries. The use of eye protection has helped
to reduce the number and severity of eye injuries. The
American Society for Testing and Materials has established
performance standards for selected eyewear. Consultation
with an eye care professional is recommended for fitting
protective eyewear. The functionally one-eyed, or monocular,
athlete should take extra precautions. A preparticipation
eye examination is helpful in identifying persons who may
be at increased risk for eye injury. Sports-related eye
injuries should be evaluated on site with an adequate examination
of the eye and adnexa. Minor eye injuries may be treated
on site. The team physician must know which injuries require
immediate referral to an ophthalmologist and the guidelines
for returning an athlete to competition.
Skateboard-associated injuries: participation-based
estimates and injury characteristics. Kyle SB, Nance ML, Rutherford
GW Jr, Winston FK. Epidemiology
and Health Statistics, Consumer Product Safety Commission,
Bethesda, Maryland, USA. J Trauma. 2002 Oct;53(4):686-90
BACKGROUND: Skateboarding is a popular recreational activity
but has attendant associated risks. To place this risk
in perspective, participation-based rates of injury were
determined and compared with those of other selected sports.
Skateboard-associated injuries were evaluated over time
to determine participation-based trends in injury prevalence.
METHODS: Rates of skateboard-associated injury were studied
for the 12-year period 1987 to 1998 for participants aged
7 years or older. The National Electronic Injury Surveillance
System provided injury estimates for skateboarding and
the selected additional sporting activities. The National
Sporting Goods Association annual survey of nationally
representative households provided participation estimates.
A participation-based rate of injury was calculated from
these data sets for the selected sports for the year 1998.
RESULTS: The 1998 rate of emergency department-treated
skateboard-associated injuries-8.9 injuries per 1,000 participants
(95% confidence interval [CI], 6.2, 11.6)-was twice as
high as in-line skating (3.9 [95% CI, 3.1, 4.8]) and half
as high as basketball (21.2 [95% CI, 18.3, 24.1]). The
rate of skateboard-associated injuries declined from 1987
to 1993 but is again increasing: the 1998 rate was twice
that of 1993 (4.5 [95% CI, 1.6, 7.4] and 8.9 [95% CI, 6.2,
11.6], respectively). Increases occurred primarily among
adolescent and young adult skateboarders. The most frequent
injuries in 1998 were ankle strain/sprain and wrist fracture:
1.2 (95% CI, 0.8, 1.6) and 0.6 (95% CI, 0.4, 0.8) per 1,000,
respectively. Skateboard-associated injuries requiring
hospitalization occurred in 2.9% and were 11.4 (95% CI,
7.5, 17.5) times more likely to have occurred as a result
of a crash with a motor vehicle than injuries in those
patients not hospitalized. CONCLUSION: This study is the
first to relate skateboarding and other sport injuries
to participation exposures. We found that skateboarding
is a comparatively safe sport; however, increased rates
of injury are occurring in adolescent and young adult skateboarders.
The most common injuries are musculoskeletal; the more
serious injuries resulting in hospitalization typically
involve a crash with a motor vehicle. This new methodology
that uses participation-based injury rates might contribute
to more effective injury control initiatives.
Dental trauma and level of information:
mouthguard use in different contact sports. Ferrari CH, Ferreria
de Mederios JM. Department of Dentistry,
Biology and Health Center, Sao Francisco University, Braganca
Paulista, Sao Paulo, Brazil. Dent Traumatol. 2002 Jun;18(3):144-7
The objective of the present work was to study the occurrence
of dental trauma in different sports, as well as to check
if athletes used mouthguard during sport activities, and
knew the significance of its utilization. The professional
and semi-professional athletes who practised contact sports
were interviewed, and were analyzed to determine the occurrence
of dental trauma during sport practice, as well as if the
athletes used a mouthguard and knew its indication. Results
showed a high rate of dental trauma in athletes compared
to the general population. The majority of athletes also
demonstrated little utilization of mouthguard, in spite
of the information about usage during sports practices
and a general knowledge of its uses.
Catastrophic pediatric sports injuries. Luckstead
EF, Patel DR. Pediatric Medicine Department,
Texas Tech Medical School-Amarillo, 1400 Coulter Drive,
Amarillo, TX 79160, USA. Pediatr Clin North Am. 2002 Jun;49(3):581-91
The high school sports of wrestling, gymnastics, ice hockey,
baseball, track, and cheerleading should receive closer
attention to prevent injury. Safer equipment and sport-specific
conditioning should be provided and injuries strictly monitored.
Greater attention must also be paid to swimming and diving
techniques, and continued observation is needed for heat
stroke and heat intolerance in sports such as football,
wrestling, basketball, track and field, and cross-country.
An increased awareness of commotio cordis in sports other
than baseball should include ice hockey, football, track
field events, and lacrosse. American football because of
the sheer numbers and associated catastrophic injury potential
must continue to be monitored at the highest medical levels!
Is it possible to prevent sports injuries?
Review of controlled clinical trials and recommendations
for future work. Parkkari J, Kujala UM, Kannus P. Tampere Research Center
of Sports Medicine, President Urho Kaleva Kekkonen Institute
for Health Promotion Research,
Finland. Sports Med. 2001;31(14):985-95
Sports injuries are one of the most
common injuries in modern western societies. Treating
sports injuries is often
difficult, expensive and time consuming, and thus, preventive
strategies and activities are justified on medical as well
as economic grounds. A successful injury surveillance and
prevention requires valid pre- and post-intervention data
on the extent of the problem. The aetiology, risk factors
and exact mechanisms of injuries need to be identified
before initiating a measure or programme for preventing
sports injuries, and measurement of the outcome (injury)
must include a standardised definition of the injury and
its severity, as well as a systematic method of collecting
the information. Valid and reliable measurement of the
exposure includes exact information about the population
at risk and exposure time. The true efficacy of a preventive
measure or programme can be best evaluated through a well-planned
randomised trial. Until now, 16 randomised, controlled
trials (RCT) have been published on prevention of sports
injuries. According to these RCT, the general injury rate
can be reduced by a multifactorial injury prevention programme
in soccer (relative risk 0.25, p < 0.001, in the intervention
group), or by ankle disk training, combined with a thorough
warm-up, in European team handball [odds ratio 0.17; 95%
confidence interval (CI) 0.09 to 0.32, p < 0.01]. Ankle
sprains can be prevented by ankle supports (i.e. semirigid
orthoses or air-cast braces) in high-risk sporting activities,
such as soccer and basketball (Peto odds ratio 0.49; 95%
CI 0.37 to 0.66), and stress fractures of the lower limb
by the use of shock-absorbing insoles in footwear (Peto
odds ratio 0.47; 95% CI 0.30 to 0.76). In future studies,
it is extremely important for researches to seek consultation
with epidemiologists and statisticians to be certain that
the study hypothesis is appropriate and that the methodology
can lead to reliable and valid information. Further well-designed
randomised studies are needed on preventive actions and
devices that are in common use, such as preseason medical
screenings, warming up, proprioceptive training, stretching,
muscle strengthening, taping, protective equipment, rehabilitation
programmes and education interventions (such as increasing
general injury awareness among a team). The effect of a
planned rule change on the injury risk in a particular
sport could be tested via a RCT before execution of the
change. The most urgent needs are in commonly practised
or high-risk sports, such as soccer, American football,
rugby, ice hockey, European team handball, karate, floorball,
basketball, downhill skiing and motor sports.
A prospective study of injuries in basketball:
a total profile and comparison by gender and standard of
competition. McKay GD, Goldie PA, Payne WR, Oakes BW, Watson
LF. School
of Physiotherapy, La Trobe University, Victoria, Australia. J Sci Med Sport. 2001 Jun;4(2):196-211
The study aimed to determine prospectively
a basketball injury profile, including severity of injury,
and to compare
the injury profile by gender and standard of competition.
Trained observers viewed basketball games, noting the occurrence
of injuries, and confirmed injuries by questioning all
players on site after the game. Injured players completed
a questionnaire and the progress of their injury was monitored
by telephone interview. A total of 10,393 basketball participations
were observed. An overall injury rate was documented of
18.3 per 1,000 participations (24.7 per 1,000 playing hours),
and was comparable by gender and standard of competition.
Serious injuries (missing one or more weeks of play) occurred
at a rate of 2.89/1,000 participations; with the ankle
joint the most common serious injury (1.25/1,000 participations),
followed by the calf/anterior leg (0.48/1,000 participations)
and knee joint (0.29/1,000 participations). The severity
of the injury was significantly associated with the body
region injured, with more serious injuries incurred to
the lower limb than other body regions (p <.05). The
severity of the injury incurred was not related to the
standard of competition, gender, age, height, number of
games played per week, amount of training undertaken, type
of injury, or the mechanism of injury (p> .05).
The sprained ankle. Puffer JC. Division of Sports Medicine, Department of Family
Medicine, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, California,
USA. Clin Cornerstone. 2001;3(5):38-49
The sprained ankle is the most common musculoskeletal
injury seen by physicians caring for active youngsters
and adults. It accounts for approximately one fourth of
all sports-related injuries and is commonly seen in athletes
participating in basketball, soccer, or football. It has
been shown that one third of West Point cadets suffer an
ankle sprain during their 4 years at the military academy.
While diagnosis and management of the sprained ankle is
usually straightforward, several serious injuries can masquerade
as an ankle sprain, and it is important for the clinician
to recognize these to prevent long-term morbidity. In this
article the basic anatomy of the ankle, mechanisms by which
the ankle is injured, and the differential diagnosis of
the acutely injured ankle are reviewed. Appropriate evaluation
of the injured ankle and the criteria that should be utilized
for determining the necessity of radiographs are discussed
as well as management of the acutely sprained ankle and
the role of prevention in reducing the risk of ankle injury.
Sports activities related to injuries?
A survey among 9-19 year olds in Switzerland. Michaud PA,
Renaud A, Narring F. Groupe de Recherche sur
la Sante des Adolescents, Institut Universitaire de Medecine
Sociale et Preventive, Lausanne,
Switzerland. Inj Prev. 2001 Mar;7(1):41-5
BACKGROUND: Most data on sports injuries are gathered
in clinical settings so that their epidemiology in the
general population is not well known. OBJECTIVE: To explore
the link between sports injuries with the type and the
amount of sports activity and biological factors. METHODS:
In 1996, 3,609 in-school adolescents 10-19 years (1,847
girls and 1,762 boys) participated in a regional survey.
This included anthropometric measurements and a self administered
questionnaire. RESULTS: Altogether 28.2% of girls and 35.9%
of boys reported one or more sports injuries during the
previous year and 2.1% of girls and 6.5% of boys reported
at least one hospitalization due to a sports injury. Using
the mean rate of injuries as reference level, some sports
are highly related to injury occurrence: body building
(relative risk (RR) 1.7, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.5
to 1.9), skateboarding and rollerskating (RR 1.6, 1.4 to
1.8), athletics (RR 1.5, 1.3 to 1.7), snowboarding (RR
1.5, 1.4 to 1.6), basketball (RR 1.3, 1.2 to 1.4), soccer
(RR 1.3, 1.2 to 1.4), and ice hockey (RR 1.2, 1.1 to 1.3).
Using a logistic regression, several variables associated
with a higher risk of injury were identified: the amount
of physical activity, high risk sports, and Tanner pubertal
stages. CONCLUSION: The risk of sports injury increases
not so much with age but with exposure to specific sports
and with pubertal development.
Football incident analysis: a new video
based method to describe injury mechanisms in professional
football. Andersen TE, Larsen O, Tenga A, Engebretsen L, Bahr
R. Oslo
Sports Trauma Research Center, Norwegian University of
Sport and Physical Education, Norway. Br J Sports Med. 2003 Jun;37(3):226-32
OBJECTIVES: To develop and test a new video based method
for match analysis that combines football specific and
medical information to achieve a better understanding of
the injury mechanisms and events leading up to high risk
situations. METHODS: Football incident analysis (FIA) is
a video based method describing incidents that may result
in an injury using 19 variables and categories modified
from match analysis. Videos from 35 of 76 (46%) official
Norwegian under 21 matches played from 1994 to 1998 were
analysed. Two football experts classified each incident
on the basis of predetermined criteria, and their results
were compared using interobserver and intraobserver reliability
tests. RESULTS: kappa correlation coefficients for interobserver
and intraobserver agreement were very good for 63% and
95% and good for 37% and 5% of the variables respectively.
Fifty two incidents were recorded (1.6 incidents per team
per match or 94 per 1000 player hours), and 16 (31%) led
to injuries (0.5 injuries per match or 29 injuries per
1000 player hours). FIA results showed that 28 incidents
occurred while attacking in midfield zone 2 or the attacking
zone, and 24 took place while defending in the defensive
zone or midfield zone 1. Midfielders were exposed in 67%
of the incidents, mainly in breakdown attacks or during
long attacks by the opposing team. Of the 28 incidents
during offence, only one was classified as having great
potential to score a goal. Most incidents (70%) were the
result of tackling duels both in the offensive and defensive
playing phases. Of the 21 offensive incidents resulting
from tackling duels, in 19 cases the exposed player was
unaware of the tackling (passive duellist). CONCLUSIONS:
This study shows that football incident analysis is a potentially
valuable tool for understanding the events leading up to
injuries in football.
Injury Risk in Men's Canada West University
Football. Hagel BE, Fick GH, Meeuwisse WH. Department of Epidemiology
and Biostatistics, Faculty of Medicine, McGill University,
Montreal, Quebec, Canada. Am J Epidemiol. 2003 May 1;157(9):825-33
Injury and participation information was collected over
5 years (1993-1997) on varsity men's football players in
the Canada West Universities Athletic Association. The
locations of acute time-loss injuries or neurologic injures
were coded as head and neck, upper extremity (shoulder
to hand), or lower extremity (hip to foot). Poisson regression-based
generalized estimating equations were used to estimate
rate ratios and 95% confidence intervals. Injury rates
were higher during games as compared with practice periods
(for the head and neck, rate ratio (RR) = 9.75 (95% confidence
interval (CI): 7.50, 12.67); for upper extremities, RR
= 5.76 (95% CI: 4.46, 7.45); and for lower extremities,
RR = 7.06 (95% CI: 6.03, 8.25)). In dry-field game situations,
head and neck injury rates were 1.59 times higher on artificial
turf than on natural grass (95% CI: 1.04, 2.42). Lower
extremity game injury rates were higher on artificial turf
than on natural grass under both dry (RR = 1.83, 95% CI:
1.35, 2.48) and wet (RR = 2.31, 95% CI: 1.18, 4.52) field
conditions. Injury rates increased with every additional
year of participation. Past injury increased the rate of
subsequent injury. The effect of an artificial field surface
may be related to infrequent use. Risk factors for injury
included participation in a game, playing on artificial
turf, being a veteran player, and having a past injury.
Sports injury or trauma? Injuries of
the competition off-road motorcyclist. Colburn NT, Meyer RD. Division of Orthopaedics, University
of Alabama Medical Center, and the Baptist Health Systems,
3317 Teakwood Road,
Birmingham, AL 35226, USA. Injury. 2003 Mar;34(3):207-14
A prospective analysis of the injuries of off-road competition
motorcyclist at four International Six Day Enduro (ISDE)
events was performed utilizing the injury severity score
(ISS) and the abbreviated injury scale (AIS). Of the 1787
participants, approximately 10% received injuries that
required attention from a medical response unit. The majority
(85%) sustained a mild injury (mean ISS 3.9). Loss of control
while jumping and striking immovable objects were important
risk determinants for serious injury. Although seasoned
in off-road experiences, mean 15.3 years, 54% of those
injured were first year rookies to the ISDE event. Speeds
were below 50 km/h in the majority of accidents (80%),
and were not statistically correlated with severity. The
most frequently injured anatomical regions were the extremities
(57%). The most common types of injury were ligamentous
(50%). Seventy-seven percent of all fractures were AIS
grades 1 and 2. The most common fractures were those of
the foot and ankle (36%). Multiple fractures involving
different anatomical regions, or a combination of serious
injuries was seen with only one rider. When compared to
the injuries of the street motorcyclist, competition riders
had lower AIS grades of head and limb trauma. Off-road
motorcycle competition is a relatively safe sport with
injury rates comparably less than those of contact sports
such as American football and hockey.
Neurovascular trauma in athletes. Koffler
KM, Kelly JD 4th. Department of Orthopaedic Surgery,
Temple University School of Medicine, Temple University
Center for Sports Medicine,
One Greentree Center, Suite 104, Marlton, NJ 08053, USA. Orthop Clin North Am. 2002 Jul;33(3):523-34, vi. Review.
Erratum in: Orthop Clin North Am. 2003 Jan;34(1):xiii
Injuries to neurovascular structures are not the most
common injuries seen in athletes and for this reason may
often be overlooked. Additionally, diagnosis and management
may be more difficult because of inexperience with these
injuries. The majority of acute sports-related neurovascular
injuries are associated with contact sports such as rugby,
wrestling, ice hockey, and especially football. These injuries
most commonly occur about the shoulder girdle and brachial
plexus, with "burners" syndrome being the most
common. Less common injuries include thoracic outlet syndrome,
effort-induced thrombosis, axillary artery occlusion, and
peripheral nerve injuries, as well as compression syndromes
involving the axillary, suprascapular, and long thoracic
nerves.